Can You Bake Potatoes Ahead Of Time (Perfect Party Food)

  • By: VidJovanovic
  • Date: January 19, 2023
  • Time to read: 6 min.

Yes, you can bake potatoes ahead of time. Just bake them until they’re partially cooked, then let them cool and store them in the fridge. When you’re ready to eat them, finish cooking them in the oven or microwave.

Key Takeaways

  • Although potatoes can be baked in advance, they won’t be as crispy as freshly baked potatoes.
  • After being baked, potatoes can be kept for up to four days in the refrigerator.
  • When reheating, potatoes should be wrapped in foil and baked for about 15 minutes at 400 degrees Fahrenheit.
  • You can also freeze baked potatoes for up to six months.
  • When thawing, place the potato in the fridge overnight and reheat as directed above.
Can You Bake Potatoes Ahead Of Time
Can You Bake Potatoes Ahead Of Time

Here’s The Answer To Can You Bake Potatoes Ahead Of Time

Potatoes can indeed be baked in advance. As a versatile vegetable, potatoes can be used in a wide range of recipes.

For up to four days, baked potatoes can be kept in the refrigerator. Always use starchy varieties such as Russet or Yukon Gold when baking potatoes.

Avoid using waxy varieties such as Red Bliss or White Rose, as they will not hold up as well when baked ahead of time.

There are several methods for baking potatoes ahead of time. Prior to placing the potatoes in the refrigerator, it is crucial to make sure they are fully cooked.

Yes, You Can Bake Potatoes Ahead Of Time

Yes You Can Bake Potatoes Ahead Of Time
Yes, You Can Bake Potatoes Ahead Of Time

It’s true. Potatoes can be baked in advance, and the process is simple. The key is to keep them in a cool place and ensure they’re dry before putting them in the oven.

If you have any leftovers from your Thanksgiving feast or want to prepare some potatoes for Monday’s lunch at work, go ahead and try this method.

Potatoes Can Be Baked Up To 24 Hours In Advance

Now you know you can bake potatoes ahead of time, but how long can you keep them?

Potatoes can be baked up to 24 hours in advance. Store them in a cool, dry place and reheat them before serving. Reheat at 325 degrees F for 20-25 minutes or until warm throughout.

Store Baked Potatoes In A Cool, Dry Place

The ideal location for baked potato storage is a cool, dry area. If you plan to store them for more than one day, wrap them in aluminum foil or plastic wrap (but do not seal the foil entirely) and place them on a shelf that’s away from heat sources like refrigerators and ovens.

If you need to store your potatoes for more than three days, freeze them immediately after taking them out of the oven—again, ensure that no moisture gets inside the potato by sealing it with plastic wrap or aluminum foil before freezing.

Reheat Baked Potatoes In A 325 Degree F Oven For 20-25 Minutes

Reheat Baked Potatoes In A 325 Degree F Oven For 20 25 Minutes
Reheat Baked Potatoes In A 325 Degree F Oven For 20-25 Minutes

Let’s be honest: we all know you can’t just reheat a baked potato in the microwave (though if you’re desperate and in a hurry, you can).

You need to bake them in a 350-degree F oven for about 30 minutes to get them back up to temp, but it’s hard not to overcook them and dry out their flesh. What do?

Simply put, there are two ways that we recommend reheating baked potatoes:

  • In an electric skillet on medium heat until hot throughout (about 10 minutes), regularly flipping as they cook; or
  • Under the broiler at high heat until hot throughout (about 5 minutes), occasionally rotating as they cook

Baked Potatoes Are Best Served Fresh, But Can Be Stored For Up To 3 Days

Can you bake potatoes ahead of time? The answer is yes, but you’ll be better off eating them fresh. If you want to bake a lot of potatoes and store them for later, they keep well in the refrigerator for up to three days.

However, don’t expect them to taste as good as they would when freshly prepared. Suppose you’re planning on using your baked potatoes in another dish (like making stuffing). In that case, it might be worthwhile forking over some time upfront so that everything comes out tasting as it should.

You may also have heard that if you refrigerate your baked potato before cooking, the texture will improve—and that’s true.

What Is The Ideal Temperature To Bake Potatoes?

What Is The Ideal Temperature To Bake Potatoes
What Is The Ideal Temperature To Bake Potatoes

The ideal temperature to bake potatoes is 400 to 425 degrees F. I know, this answer seems obvious. But the truth is that many people don’t bake their potatoes correctly.

They either put them at too high a temperature or leave them in the oven for too long; both mistakes will cause your potato to dry out and become soggy or fall apart completely.

If you’re looking for an exact time frame, it depends on what kind of potato you’re using and how big they are:

  • The general rule is that small potatoes take about 20 minutes, medium ones 30 minutes, and large ones 40 minutes—but if you’re making mashed potatoes with butter and cream sauce, then they’ll need more time in order not to get too soft (since butter melts at around 95 degrees). If possible, use an instant thermometer since it will give a more accurate reading than looking at color changes alone.
  • When done baking, you’ll know when ready because there won’t be any resistance when inserting the fork into the center.

How Long Do You Need To Bake Potatoes?

While baking potatoes is a time-consuming process, it requires little effort. You have to bake them in an oven until they are soft in the center, and then add toppings like sour cream and bacon bits.

However, there are a few crucial considerations to make when determining how long to bake your potatoes:

  • The potato size will affect how long it takes them to cook through. Smaller potatoes take less time than larger ones. For example, if you’re making two servings of baked potatoes using four medium-sized Russet potatoes each, expect that they’ll take longer than if you were only cooking one serving with just two medium-sized Russets per serving.

What Are The Benefits Of Baking Potatoes Ahead Of Time?

What Are The Benefits Of Baking Potatoes Ahead Of Time
What Are The Benefits Of Baking Potatoes Ahead Of Time

The benefits of baking potatoes ahead of time are obvious: you can have hot, ready-to-eat baked potatoes at your disposal whenever you want them.

But what about the less obvious benefits?

  • The skin on a potato is sort of like your skin—it’s protective and keeps out foreign invaders (like dirt, water, and air). So when you bake a potato fresh from the store, it’ll be covered in all its natural goodness. Once you let it cool down after cooking and cut into it, however, that creamy flesh will quickly oxidize and turn brown due to exposure to oxygen in the air around it.

If you want to keep those valuable nutrients intact while still enjoying that delicious white inside (and believe me: we do!), then by all means, go ahead and serve up some freshly-baked spuds as soon as possible after purchase.

In Summary

Although there are a few considerations, baking potatoes ahead of time is possible. You need to cook them until they’re almost done.

You need to let them cool completely before storing them in the fridge. And finally, you need to reheat them properly before serving.

If you follow these instructions, you’ll be able to enjoy delicious, freshly-baked potatoes any time you want.


Vid Jovanovic

I’m Vid Jovanovic and I’m 36 years old. I’m a teacher by profession and my passion lies in baking. I have been baking since my early teens, when my grandmother taught me how to make a simple cake that you can find in any supermarket. My passion for baking grew as I got older and I started experimenting with different ingredients and recipes.